Many boutique consultancies see hiring a new business development (BD) leader as the ultimate solution for driving growth.
The idea is simple: hire a seasoned professional to open doors, attract high-quality clients, and revitalize the sales pipeline quickly. But in my experience, this approach often backfires.
I often observed that within 12 to 24 months, these consultancies find themselves disillusioned, watching their ambitious growth plans fizzle out.
In this article, I’ll explain why newly appointed BD leaders frequently struggle to meet expectations and what foundational steps consultancies can take to prepare them for lasting success.
Why business development leaders often fail in boutique consultancies
While BD leaders are expected to attract new clients, develop existing accounts, and magically transform the business, they’re often set up to fail from day one.
After watching this pattern repeat over the years, here’s what I—and my network—have witnessed consistently go wrong.
- Unclear consultancy proposition: If the firm’s value proposition isn’t defined, the BD leader will not know what to sell, who to sell to, and how to identify opportunities. This leads to failed deals and frustration.
- No relevant consultancy experience and subject matter expertise: Without consulting experience, the BD leader might struggle with the challenges or nuances of the business. This lack of credibility hurts trust with clients and internal teams.
- Poor expertise reputation: If the consultancy doesn’t have a solid reputation as an expert, selling becomes an uphill battle. Building credibility as a consultancy takes time, but BD leaders don’t get that much time. They are typically under pressure to deliver instant results.
- Junior or generic marketing support: Inexperienced marketing teams hurt the ability to build trust at scale. ‘Doing a bit of social media’ won’t get the new BD leader there. It becomes a waste of time for everyone involved, and the messaging often gets further diluted.
- Lack of leadership support: BD leaders are often thrown in at the deep end. Boutique consultancy owners hire a BD person, provide basic training on services and operations, and then abdicate the responsibility.
- Lack of internal alignment: On the other end of the spectrum are multiple consultancy leaders/owners pulling their BD leader in different directions. When priorities change daily, it’s close to impossible to achieve measurable results.
- Inadequate resources: Hiring BD leaders from established firms only to hang them out to dry by failing to provide them with the systems, processes, and human resources they need is a surefire way to end up with disappointing results.
- Focus on new clients only: Ignoring existing clients limits growth. Retaining and developing current accounts is the real value; missing it means missed revenue and opportunities for high-margin work. Unfortunately, BD leaders rarely get involved—or are allowed to get involved—in managing and expanding existing clients.
- Outbound focus: Relying on cold outbound efforts – calls, emails, paid ads, etc. – creates inconsistent results. Consultancy sales are built on trust, credibility, and proven expertise, not hard selling. It’s a relationship-driven business where clients invest in expertise to solve complex problems, not just buy a product off the shelf. Cold outreach lacks the credibility needed to build that trust and often comes across as desperate or transactional, which turns potential clients off (and can erode the expertise's reputation).
- Disconnected from the client experience: Without firsthand experience in the consulting workflow or direct client interactions, BD leaders risk misrepresenting the consultancy’s offerings, overpromising results, or failing to convey the value. This results in dissatisfaction or mismatched expectations, harming client retention.
- Short-term pressure for results: Pressuring for quick wins leads to transactional sales, which hurts client trust and creates high churn, damaging long-term growth.
- Over-reliance on the BD leader: When the consultancy relies solely on the BD leader to drive sales, it creates a bottleneck. Sales should be a team effort, not just one person carrying the entire load.
- Inadequate data: Many boutique consultancies lack data-driven insights into client acquisition costs, conversion rates, and other KPIs. Without a solid analytics foundation, BD leaders can only rely on intuition.
Recommended reading:
How to set up the right environment for a BD leader to succeed
While I’ve seen many BD leaders crash and burn due to a mix of the reasons I’ve listed earlier, I’ve also seen cases where they were able to deliver outstanding results.
Having a dedicated business development specialist is not a mistake by default. What I urge boutique consultancies to do, though, is first to set up the right conditions—systems, processes, and approaches—for this person to thrive.
Below are the success factors that I recommend owners and senior leaders aim to accomplish first:
- Designing a precise, powerful proposition: If a BD leader doesn’t know what to sell, that’s a big problem. Senior leadership within boutique consultancies needs to fix it. This will be at the foundation of everything a BD leader does: who they reach out to, how they go about it, what type of messaging they prioritise, the value-driven pitch of services, and so on.
- Ensuring internal alignment: It’s crucial that a BD leader feels empowered. This is only possible when the entire senior leadership has this person’s back, and the leadership team is aligned around the goals and priorities.
- Hiring from the trenches: If BD leaders don't have rich consultancy experience, they are set up to fail. I recommend either appointing someone to this role from within or, if hiring from outside, looking for someone with relevant subject matter expertise and a BD drive or someone with experience in the BD role in consultancies.
- Calibrating and strengthening market reputation: Taking credibility takes time, yes, but there is no way around it. Gone are the days of cold-calling strategies delivering meaningful impact. Prospects want to trust their partners. And for that, they need to consider the consultancy as the expert in resolving particular needs.
- Investing in real marketing: Junior support means junior results. I strongly encourage boutique consultancies to think through their marketing strategy, hire experienced marketers, and foster a culture where everyone – from junior consultants to owners – contributes to marketing efforts.
- Prioritising current clients: Expanding existing accounts is the fastest way to achieve revenue stability and business growth. Instead of chasing new prospects, I suggest that boutique consultancies look inward and identify opportunities to build on their existing relationships. Not only will this help generate recurring revenue, but it will also offer consultancies a deeper understanding of the market’s needs. It will create a blueprint for BD leaders when looking to recruit long-term clients.
- Setting up support mechanisms and allocating sufficient resources: If a boutique consultancy can’t afford to allocate adequate resources towards the success of a BD leader (tech, support staff, training, etc.), then it can’t afford to hire a BD leader. It will just be months of wasted effort and money.
- Building sustainable, scalable journeys: I implore boutique consultancies to stop the cold outbound madness. I'm sorry to say that cold outbound BD in consulting is inefficient. Instead, I recommend building client success journeys that entice prospects, offer a low-risk entry service, and facilitate continuous trust-building. Inbound channels will allow BD leaders to be exponentially more effective in recruiting ideal clients.
- Making sales a collective effort: Counting on a BD leader to do all the selling is a weak strategy. Sales should be a collective effort, not a one-person show. Of course, not everyone can sell to the same degree of success – or allocate the same amount of time. However, growing the consultancy’s reputation for high-value expertise, engaging in conversations with prospects, and presenting unified messaging – these elements should be a part of the culture of a boutique consultancy.
- Thinking long-term: Pressuring for quick results destroys long-term growth and motivation. There are no quick wins when building a sustainable growth mechanism. For example, audience education-based marketing and business development take time to set up and propagate. However, the long-term results that boutique consultancies can derive are massive. Such strategies might be laborious at first, but they allow consultancies to decrease client acquisition costs in the long run continuously!
- Being diligent about data collection: BD leaders are more likely to succeed if they make data-driven decisions: who is more likely to buy when.
Recommended reading:
In conclusion
Hiring a business development leader is not a silver bullet for driving growth in boutique consultancies. While certainly an important role to fill for a business's growth, consultancies must actively take steps and measures to prepare these people for success.
Furthermore, to minimise the risk of failure, I urge boutique consultancies to build a growth-driven culture where client acquisition is a collective effort instead of putting all hopes and dreams in a single BD person. This involves crafting a solid market reputation, aligning all team members around shared goals, and continuously developing existing client relationships.
Boutique consultancies can achieve more resilient and sustainable growth by recognizing that business development is not a one-person job but a collaborative, strategic effort.
Interested in receiving all my learnings to build a better consultancy?
Subscribe to my newsletter.